Big-box stores have become a dominant force in retail, offering vast product selections under one roof at a competitive price. According to the Department of Energy, big-box chains represent 82% of the US retail market. But how do they keep costs down, even as inflation pushes prices up elsewhere?
Look no further than Costco’s famous hot dog and soda combo. Since the mid-1980s, this beloved meal has stood firm at $1.50, defying inflation that would have pushed it to $4.40 today. Yes, it’s a cheap lunch, but also a symbol of how big-box retailers win customer loyalty.
This pricing magic isn’t limited to hot dogs. From Walmart’s market dominance to Home Depot’s DIY empire, big-box stores have mastered the art of offering more for less. But at what cost?
Ahead, explore the world of big-box retail, its impact on local communities, and what big- box retail means for smaller businesses.
Characteristics of big-box retailers
Here’s what makes a retail store become considered “big box”:
- Large physical stores
- Wide variety of merchandise
- Budget-friendly pricing
- DIY shopping
- Big parking lots
- Strategic suburban locations
- Warehouse style design
- Convenience
- Self-serve model
- Inventory management needs
Large physical stores
The most obvious characteristic of big-box retailers is their sheer size. These stores are massive, often covering more than 50,000 square feet of retail space.
To put this in perspective, a big-box store can be about the size of a football field, or 20 tennis courts combined. This vast space allows big-box retailers to stock an enormous variety of products under one roof.
Wide variety of merchandise
Big-box stores are known for their variety of products. These retailers typically stock items across numerous categories, from groceries and household goods to electronics, clothing, and even automotive supplies. Customers can find almost everything they need in a single shopping trip, making these retailers a one-stop shop for many consumers.
Budget-friendly pricing
One of the main draws of big-box retailers is their pricing. These stores offer lower prices on high-ticket items than smaller, specialty retailers. They achieve this through economies of scale, or buying products in massive quantities directly from manufacturers.
Many big-box stores also offer bulk purchasing options, so customers can buy large quantities of items at even lower per-unit prices.
DIY shopping
Big-box stores typically employ a self-service model. Customers browse and select items on their own, without much help from staff. Some don’t even need cashiers as they adopt technology like Sam’s Club Scan and Go. Operating with fewer employees relative to store size helps these retailers offer significantly lower prices.
Big parking lots
Big department stores usually feature expansive parking lots to accommodate the high volume of shoppers. The typical Walmart has around 3.5 spaces per 1,000 square feet. While that number has shrunk since the early 2000s, ample parking space is still a major element of big-box retailers.
Strategic suburban locations
Many big-box retailers choose to locate their stores in suburban areas. Besides having fewer vendors to meet consumers needs, the suburbs also has several advantages:
- More available land for large stores and parking lots
- Lower real estate costs compared to urban centers
- Proximity to residential areas where many of their target customers live
- Easy access for both customers and delivery trucks
Warehouse style design
The interior of big-box stores often resembles a warehouse. High ceilings, wide aisles, and simple décor are common features. The no-frills approach keeps costs down and reinforces the image of value pricing.
Convenience
Big-box retailers typically win on convenience—there’s a local store nearby where customers can drop by and collect a product without too much disruption in their daily routine. Shoppers can also use alternative fulfillment options, like placing their order online and collecting or returning it when they’re passing by.
Self-serve model
Big-box brands often use retail technology like mobile apps and self-checkout that lets customers place orders without any assistance from customer support teams. This technology is often off limits for smaller retailers with budget constraints.
Inventory management needs
Big-box retailers operate multiple stores and often have warehouses to hold unsold inventory and ensure a continuous product supply. There’s a strong requirement for a multi-location inventory management system that shows accurate inventory levels across all storage locations.
Examples of major big-box retailers
Chances are you’ve shopped in a big-box retail store at least once in your life. Here’s a list of the major big-box retailers:
- Walmart: Walmart operates more than 10,500 stores and 380 distribution centers worldwide, and owns roughly 6.3% of the market share in the US. It offers fresh produce, bakery, electronics, apparel, home furnishings, and more. The typical Walmart is around 182,000 square feet.
- Target: Target has nearly 2,000 stores in the US, offering everything from sports and fitness products to entertainment, clothing, baby, and perishable items. Sizes range from several thousand to more than 200,000 square feet. Most of the US population lives within 10 miles of a Target store.
- Home Depot: The DIY chain Home Depot employs more than 475,000 associates in over 2,300 stores. It offers home improvement products like appliances, power tools, kitchen remodeling, and patio furniture. It currently has more than 12% of the market share relative to its competitors.
- Mastermind Toys: A Canadian retailer of specialty toys with almost 50 retail locations across the country selling 10,000 SKUs.
- Tesco: UK-based retailer Tesco is the third-largest retailer in the world with more than 4,600 locations, averaging around 70,000 square feet each. It offers a full range of in-store services like pharmacy and optical, as well as books, clothing, furniture, software, petrol, and more.
- Flying Tiger: A Danish variety store retailer that sells gifts to customers in 36 countries through 950 stores across the world. It employs more than 7,500 people.
- Costco: The Costco membership warehouse club has only 884 stores worldwide. However, with an average store size running from 80,000 to 230,000 square feet, the company still made more than $242 billion in revenue in 2023. Consumers can get “low warehouse prices” on name-brand products, from jewelry to baked goods.
- IKEA: IKEA has become the seventh most valuable retail brand in the world since 2008. Operating 473 stores in 63 markets, shoppers can browse products in the categories like storage and organization, beds, kitchen, lighting, home textiles, kitchenware, and more.
- Toby’s Sports: The Philippines’ first—and largest—specialty sports store. The retailer sells over 100,000 different products across 67 retail locations.
How do you get into big-box retailers?
With shelf space in major retailers, you get access to their established customer base and benefit from their marketing power. While the process can be challenging, the rewards of breaking into big-box retail include more retail sales and business growth.
Mike D, the founder of Mike D’s BBQ, knows this journey well. His sauce line went from a home kitchen experiment to gracing the shelves of stores across the eastern United States.
After his first pitch flopped, he learned quickly. He recommends:
- Preparing a compelling sell sheet
- Bringing samples to your meeting
- Highlighting current sales and social media following
- Demonstrating reliable fulfillment capabilities
Large retailers have a formal process for pitching products. Check the retailer’s website or call its corporate phone number to inquire about who their buyers are and how they accept pitches.
📚 Read: How To Get Your Product in Stores: 6 Steps (2024)
Big-box retailers vs. small business
Price
Big-box stores usually win on price. They can negotiate better deals with suppliers and pass the savings on to customers. Small businesses don’t buy as much, so their prices are often higher. Customers may pay a bit more, but the trade-off is supporting a local business.
Quantity
If customers want everything in one place, big-box stores usually have them covered. They stock pretty much everything from appliances to toys, fresh produce, and makeup.
Small businesses have a more limited selection and may not always have items in stock. They focus on specific product categories or niche markets, like rare teas or used vinyl records.
Shopping experience
Big-box stores are like the fast food of shopping—quick, easy, and customers know exactly what they’re getting. Small businesses have a more personalized atmosphere with unique décor and curated product displays. The shopping experience feels more intimate and less overwhelming.
Customer service
Small businesses often shine in customer service. Their staff are usually knowledgeable and might even remember a customer’s name and preferences. At big-box stores, you’ll find more staff but they may not know as much about each product. Returns are usually easier at big-box retailers, too.
Inventory management
It’s easier to get visibility into your inventory if you’re operating a single store. But when warehouse space gets bigger, SKU lists expand, and you’re holding inventory in different places, it presents the need for a multi-location inventory management system.
Headcount, roles, and responsibilities
Headcount is a big differentiator between smaller brands and big-box retailers. Larger stores might need procurement experts, customer service team members, and store managers to keep retail operations running smoothly. More products and more customers simply requires more hands on deck.
Smaller stores, however, might only have a team of three that are responsible for everything. It’s not uncommon for a retail associate in a small store to switch between tasks like processing orders, talking to customers, and conducting inventory counts.
Supply chain and procurement
Big-box retailers resell products from multiple vendors. Most have account managers to maintain the relationship with a particular supplier. It’s their job to negotiate payment terms, bulk discounts, and delivery timeframes.
Smaller businesses typically have one or two merchandising experts that oversee the supply chain process. You’re maintaining relationships with several suppliers simultaneously (as opposed to one larger vendor).
Impact on local economies
Job creation vs. displacement
Big-box retailers create new jobs but often displace existing ones. When a large store opens, it typically hires hundreds of workers. However, this can lead to job losses at smaller local businesses that can’t compete.
A landmark study found that for every job created by Walmart, 1.4 jobs are lost at other local businesses—a net decrease in total jobs. On average, counties where Walmart built stores experienced a net loss of about 150 retail jobs within five years.
Competition
Big-box stores significantly impact local businesses through intense competition. Their massive scale allows them to offer lower prices, which can be tough for specialty stores to match.
Tax revenue generation
Large chain stores, in theory, should boost local tax revenues, but the picture is complex. They often receive tax breaks or incentives to build in an area. One study found that local retailers return 52% of their revenue to the local economy, compared to just 14% for national chain retailers.
Environmental impact
Big discount stores like Target and Walmart create a large environmental footprint. These companies have thousands of stores covering hundreds of millions of square feet of retail space, not including parking or distribution centers.
Together, they harm the environment, including traffic congestion and air and water pollution. In fact, a 2024 report from the Environmental Defense Fund and ElectrifyNY, found that distribution facilities generate more than 170,000 truck trips per day. The report endorsed that storage and distribution centers larger than 50,000 square feet be classified as indirection pollution sources and require them to reduce transportation-related air emissions.
Between increasing regulations and corporate responsibility, some big-box stores are working to improve their environmental practices, like installing solar panels and using more efficient lighting.
Sell more in your retail store with Shopify POS
Businesses of all sizes thrive by playing to their strengths—personalized service, curated selections, and deep community ties.
Shopify POS offers smart inventory tools, customer insights, and omnichannel sales that support you at all stages of your retail business. Whether you’re opening your first pop-up or launching your 100th store location, Shopify’s best-in-class point of sale solution can help you manage it all.
Big-box retailer FAQ
What is the most popular big-box store?
Walmart is generally considered the most popular big-box store in the United States. It leads in terms of total sales, number of locations, and customer traffic across the country.
Is Target a big-box retailer?
Yes, Target is definitely considered a big-box retailer. It operates large-format stores offering a wide variety of merchandise, including groceries, clothing, electronics, and home goods, which is characteristic of big-box retail.
How do you compete against big-box retailers?
To compete with big-box stores, focus on what makes your business special. Offer top-notch customer service, stock unique products they can’t find elsewhere, and really get to know your local community’s needs. Being smaller can be an advantage. For example, you can change things up quickly when customers want something new.
