A fierce independent streak is an essential ingredient in launching and sustaining a startup. But it’s just as important to recognize and capitalize on the benefits of a dynamic startup community or ecosystem.
Data shows startups are most successful when run from within robust startup ecosystems, like the San Francisco Bay Area. Even though San Francisco and Silicon Valley are the most famous examples of these sorts of communities, entrepreneurs have plenty of other options as well. So what elements should an entrepreneur look for when setting out to put down roots? Why opt for a San Francisco, a Boston, or a Bangalore over a small town? What qualities and resources should you consider?
Let’s explore the answers to these questions and more, so you have all the information you need to start thinking about where your startup might thrive.
What is a startup ecosystem?
A startup ecosystem is a dynamic network of people and organizations offering resources that contribute to startup success.
There’s a strong case for setting up in a specific geographical location with a renowned local startup ecosystem. More often than not, location is key—major metropolitan areas like Los Angeles and Shanghai boast access to critical networking opportunities and funding sources that other smaller cities and suburbs don’t.
But the elements of a startup ecosystem can—and often do—come together in virtual spaces and online communities like social media sites, internet forums, and mastermind groups. With the rise of remote work and international teams, it’s possible to develop a truly global startup ecosystem.
Elements of a startup ecosystem
- Many other startups and entrepreneurs
- Skilled local talent
- Tech-focused educational institutions
- Incubators and accelerators
- Coworking spaces
- Networks of experienced mentors
- Investors and financing
- Government resources
A viable startup ecosystem is quite intricate. To thrive, it requires the right combination of some essential components. These elements can include:
Many other startups and entrepreneurs
Competition and diversity make for a rich and bustling startup ecosystem. Cities with at least 1,000 local startups promote healthy competitiveness, dynamic entrepreneurial culture, and mutually beneficial exchange of innovative ideas. Top-performing startup ecosystems like New York City boast more than 25,000 startups.
Skilled local talent
It’s no coincidence startups historically have chosen to set up shop in popular, world-class cities. The competition to attract top talent is fierce, and the best and brightest want to work in cities that are also pleasant and stimulating to live in.
A good ecosystem will have access to these software engineers, salespeople, and product managers—and the work these professionals produce will benefit from the high quality of life they experience off the clock.
Tech-focused educational institutions
Universities with strong technical programs benefit startup ecosystems in two major ways. First, every year a new crop of highly coveted tech talent hits the labor market. And second, universities like Stanford, Caltech, MIT, Tsinghua, and École Polytechnique are hotbeds of research and innovation.
These hallowed halls can and do inform the ideas explored in their surrounding ecosystems. They sometimes even offer their own funding and facilities for local entrepreneurs to take advantage of.
Incubators and accelerators
A thriving startup ecosystem boasts a wide array of entrepreneurial support organizations like business incubators and startup accelerator programs. These offer a vital combination of networking opportunities and small-scale funding for entrepreneurs. They’re a valuable early stage fertilizer for any startup ecosystem.
Coworking spaces
For early stage startups, coworking spaces are an affordable office space option that simultaneously offer a variety of networking resources. Entrepreneurs in coworking spaces get to work side by side with other entrepreneurs, fostering network growth and healthy competition. Additionally, coworking spaces often host supportive community events to facilitate sharing ideas and keeping each other motivated.
Networks of experienced mentors
Expert mentoring is a key ingredient in successful startup ventures. Advice from founders who’ve traveled the startup journey before helps new founders establish credibility, build vital industry relationships, move forward efficiently, and avoid potentially costly mistakes.
🌟Looking for a mentor? Discover how to find a business mentor and learn why every entrepreneur can benefit from having one.
Investors and financing
No matter where a startup is located, one reality remains steadfast: Entrepreneurs need money to grow their ventures. To launch and run a successful startup, founders need regular access to angel investors and funding organizations (banks, venture capital firms, etc.) who are willing to take risks on new businesses.
Often, you’ll find these investors and organizations in major cities. While cold-emailing is often the main method of fundraising, face-to-face networking events can give entrepreneurs a major leg up.
Government resources
Certain city, state, and even national government organizations offer initiatives, tax breaks, and sometimes direct funding to attract entrepreneurs and startups to their respective locales.
For example, the state government of Massachusetts offers a variety of small business grants designed for new startups. The Dutch government’s Enterprise Agency offers a well-known innovation credit scheme. And in some instances, even the foreign diplomatic offices of some countries offer funding opportunities abroad—such as this US-backed entrepreneurship program in Brazil.
How do startup ecosystems develop?
The startup ecosystem lifecycle is a framework developed by Startup Genome for classifying startup ecosystems based on maturity. There are a range of external and internal factors that affect development.
Each specific development stage has its drawbacks and benefits—relatively lower and higher barriers to entry, different levels of competition, and so on. Knowing an ecosystem’s lifecycle stage can help determine whether it boasts the right resources and financial climate for your startup. The phases of different startup ecosystems are:
Activation phase
In the activation phase, a startup ecosystem may not have much in the way of a robust investor or talent network. It will usually have fewer than 1,000 startups. To move out of the activation phase, organizations typically focus on identifying strong, distinct industries in the community and develop programs to accelerate ideas and startups in these fields.
Globalization phase
During the globalization phase, a startup ecosystem will boast up to 2,000 startups and a few eye-catching exits (sales of startups or IPOs) in the $100 million range. These exits attract more entrepreneurs, investors, and other funding providers to the area.
To move out of the globalization phase, entrepreneurs start to focus efforts to better control ecosystem processes, build bridges with colleagues in more established ecosystems, and help local ventures extend global reach.
Attraction phase
Startup ecosystems in the attraction phase usually have more than 2,000 startups, and unicorn valuations or exits above $1 billion. These impressive buyouts, plus fewer resource gaps, attract even more resource inputs (like talent and investment capital) to the region, which in turn focus on big-market disruptions.
Moving out of the attraction phase into the final phase of the startup ecosystem lifecycle entails filling what few success-factor gaps remain and continuing to attract talent. This can be achieved by working with government support to favorably influence external factors and the supportive environment, such as reducing regulatory barriers to immigration.
Integration phase
A successful startup ecosystem that reaches the integration phase will boast more than 3,000 startups. Ecosystems at this phase are deeply embedded in the global market and may even have footprints in multiple integration-phase startup communities (offices in San Francisco, New York, and Shanghai, for example). Integration-phase ecosystems focus on influencing national and global policies that foster continued economic growth at home and around the world.
Benefits of startup ecosystems
The benefits of operating your startup in a startup ecosystem are many, and these advantages flow not only to the startup itself but to its employees and the surrounding community and local markets.
- Business benefits: A startup ecosystem can provide businesses with tax incentives, access to a skilled workforce, and proximity to major funding providers.
- Employee benefits: Startup ecosystems provide workers relative job security (qualified employees can easily find new work), competitive compensation, and a high quality of life outside of work.
- Community benefits: Startup ecosystems boast higher employment rates, increased tax income, more tourism, higher living standards, boosted national and international recognition, and an overall more invigorated local economy.
The extent and impact of these benefits will depend largely on the level of active startup ecosystem management at play (from both internal factors and local government).
Startup ecosystem FAQ
What are the top startup ecosystems?
According to Forbes, the top 10 global startup ecosystems are:
1. San Francisco, United States
2. New York, United States
3. London, United Kingdom
4. Los Angeles, United States
5. Boston, United States
6. Beijing, China
7. Shanghai, China
8. Bangalore, India
9. Tel Aviv-Yafo, Israel
10. Paris, France
What are the different phases of a startup ecosystem?
It’s in the name—startup ecosystems develop startups. They offer access to vital resources that allow startups to successfully launch, grow, and sustain themselves in the long term.
What do startup ecosystems produce?
It’s in the name—startup ecosystems develop startups. They offer access to vital resources that allow startups to successfully launch, grow, and sustain themselves in the long term.
